3
$\begingroup$

Since 2.82 some of the physics systems have undergone some major changes, specifically Fluid (when mantaflow was added). As such, for the site it seems to creates a bit of a mess with some tags because they overlap.


excerpt as of this writing:

Questions about the Fluid simulation systems in blender. Blender has two systems for simulating liquids, a SPH (Smoothed Particle Dynamics) system integrated with the particle system, and a Lattice Boltzmann method which can be used create a variety of simulations.


is actually an old wiki link as of writing this question, which is how this question came up in the first place.

no tag wiki

For a user that reads the tag wiki, this would be misleading, so the information should probably be updated.

Per current documentation, fluid simulation includes smoke/ fire and liquid, so wouldn't be surprised if users unknowingly begin to misuse for both causing future disorganization of questions as time goes on.

Examples of questions that was asked are Both my fire emitter and my domain became 'wireframe', can't see them in render view

The OP is asking about fire, but tagged the question as well as

also,

Cold smoke simulation

The OP is asking about smoke but has tagged the question and

Finally, these two tag search results here and here show that it is already becoming quite disorganized.


The question
How should these tags be organized? The given information needs to be updated. So while at it, is it a good idea to create a new tag, and use that for questions specifically about liquid, and use for specific smoke questions, and then use or create for both of these?

$\endgroup$
3
  • $\begingroup$ Perhaps we could include a notice that the old tags are now deprecated and reference which new tag should be used instead. I'm not sure how often questions about mantaflow are asked, it may make sense to have specific tags for simulation types for mantaflow (e.g. mantaflow-fluid, mantaflow-fire, mantaflow-smoke) $\endgroup$
    – Robert Gützkow Mod
    Oct 29 '20 at 19:45
  • $\begingroup$ @RobertGützkow perhaps, at a glance it seems that smoke-simulation has had 15 questions this month, fluid-simulation 31, and fire has had 7. At the same time, I know there are users that still use old versions because of their hardware, so still may run into questions for now... $\endgroup$
    – Timaroberts Mod
    Oct 29 '20 at 21:22
  • $\begingroup$ I think fluid-simulation and smoke-simulation should be kept system agnostic as tags respectively pertaining to fluid and smoke, regardless of the underlying system. The fact that it now uses Mantaflow library or that both use the same system under the hood seems irrelevant and should probably not be reflected in our tags. Having additional liquid-simulation or mantaflow tags will probably only add to the confusion. Incorrectly tagged questions should be fixed of course. $\endgroup$ Oct 30 '20 at 13:34

You must log in to answer this question.

Browse other questions tagged .